Join our

mailing list.

Keep up to date with our latest insights.

Friday Workplace Briefing

Why Ai redundancy- the sudden surge of Ai redundancies, why, which industries will be most affected and what is the future?

Am AI Redundant? The sudden surge in AI driven redundancies, which industries it has hit, why and where to from here?
In this Friday Workplace Briefing, Andrew and Kim discuss a recent wave of redundancies and question how much of it is due to AI. They look at the different industries being affected, why employers should test AI, and whether automating a role is enough for a genuine redundancy under the Fair Work Act.
Watch this week’s Friday Workplace Briefing Video here.

Stay updated with our Friday Workplace Briefing

Subscribe to receive the latest Friday Workplace Briefing in your inbox every Friday, where you can hear the critical news and developments that affect your workplace.

Listen to podcast

About the Hosts

Principal Lawyer - Head of Workplace Relations

Episode Transcript

Andrew Douglas: For the main topic. I think in the last three or four months, what have we seen? We’ve seen a massive surge in AI usage. We’ve seen banks, not just the Commonwealth Bank, but a large number of people who do repetitive acts or analytical acts that can be managed by using AI are being made redundant. We’re seeing it now in tech giants like Canva, but it’s happening throughout the world. Although it’s happening in Australia, it’s happening throughout the world as well. And we’re starting to see in places which have cost pressures on them, like private schools, like Ballarat Grammar School, to look at things they can wrap up, to not have to pay people to do.

Now, throughout the whole of professional services and through all work, payrolls are now being done everywhere around the world, but in Australia. So there is a whole range of roles which both AI and outsourcing are attacking. And they’re attacking them because it’s too expensive to do it here. There’s insufficiently trained people here. There’s a talent shortage that sits around. There’s so many reasons. And I think that people need to be clear that as change happens and happens so rapidly, the consultation process required under safety law is almost always ignored. They’ll make the definite decision under an award and go, “We’ve made a definite decision, so I’ll go and say to Kim, how can I prevent the impact upon you?

How can I assist you? I’ll give you some outplacement services.” But that doesn’t protect Kim, and it doesn’t protect the job. What safety says, as I contemplate making change, I must consult with Kim about what is the nature of the change that could be made? What are the hazards that would create for her? It makes me feel unsafe. Okay, but that’s a hazard. It makes me scared I’m going to lose my job. In safety law, that’s a hazard. So building that structure of communication engagement, so Kim is coming on the journey. Kim may say, “So there will become a time when I lose my job.” Well, she can start planning, but she can’t start planning after a definite decision has been made. And what we’re seeing with Canva is both reputational attack, and I suspect we’re going to see industrial attack on it. And for Australian employers, that means the industrializing of decision-making. It means getting both a regulator and a union coming in and saying, “You’re breaching safety law.”

And then we start to see prohibition notices. And all this happened in the university. So four universities went through this exact process, partly driven by AI, partly driven by cost, put out a redundancy plan where definite decision was being made, and all of them got stop orders, prohibition notices, all sorts of things to stop it, because they were damaging people while they were having the discussions, because they didn’t say to people, “We have this issue a year ago. We need to find some method of meeting the cost, the delivery of service. We understand that may impact you. We need to talk with you about how to do that. We need to assess what the level…”

It’s not hard stuff, but because AI is moving at speed, because Australian costs are going up so sharply, because our talent pool is so low, people are pressing the button. And as they’re doing it, they’re damaging reputations, they’re drawing in the regulator, they’re drawing in unions, and their brand is trash, okay? So interestingly, as an aside, unrelated, interesting article that came out about the level of mortgage fraud when the two major, three major banks over the last three years have got rid of the second tier of mortgage, but they’ve all gone into mortgage broking. Now the banks are experiencing a level of mortgage fraud because the people who they got rid of are coming back. Anyway, that’s a different side.

So for AI redundancy, I guess what we’ve got to say, we’ve seen Canva, we’ve seen WiseTech, we’ve seen Atlassian, Westpac recently, huge numbers of people gone. Australia is, its lowest skill base, non-strategic white collar is under siege, and the next five years are going to be really horrible for that group of people. And we should be saying as employers now, what does AI look like, like you and I are doing? How does it create excellence? What will it look like in six months, one year, two years? And starting to have those very deliberate conversation with what the future looks like. But it doesn’t always have to mean headcount loss if it’s done correctly. So I think an interesting story and really interesting to watch where we go, but pretty sad at the moment, because we’re seeing lots of people lose their jobs.

Kim McLagan: Yeah, I must say I’m pretty happy to be at this end of my career and not at Vivian’s end of the career where all the major changes.

Andrew Douglas: Nobody can see Vivian, but she’s over there. But I agree with you. I think that when… So one of the discussions, there’s an interesting study that came out of fertility rates between our generations and the generations that are coming through. And Australia’s growing at the rate of 1.4, which is less than replacement level. So if Australia doesn’t get migration, we will reduce them. We average at the moment two and a half people working to each person demographically retiring, whereas 20 years ago, we had six to one. So the cost of the Australian economy supporting the Australian economy around health, all those sorts of things is going through the roof. But the study then looked at the attitude of children as to having, when

I say children, people under 25, as to their ideas about having children, and their view is as a consensus, we are uncomfortable having children, bring them into a world of such uncertainty. So we’re going to see this continued reduction in fertility rates because the world is so disruptive, so concerning. So we’re seeing in spending behaviors where the saving mentality, post Second World War people like me, I didn’t get it by the way, had a much stronger saving mentality. People are inclined to go and enjoy life now because life is seen as ethereal. It could be here today, gone tomorrow. So it is challenging, isn’t it? As you say, I’m happy we’re here. Why don’t we jump into the case study?

Kim McLagan: Okay, let’s do that. “Time was taking its toll on Missie. Her fatigue became more profound after another about of lupus. She needed to take time off work more often. The butterfly rash kept returning, along with joint pain, swelling and relentless fatigue. It had been two months since Missie had worked. She wanted to work and dreamed of returning, but every morning she struggled to open her eyes. She had a high temperature and overwhelming fatigue. Missie pressed her doctor to approve her return-to-work programmed. Reluctantly, he agreed, and he prepared a gradual return-to-work plan. Her first day back at work was uneventful, but she worked for only two hours, and there was little she could do.

By the third day, fatigue had spread through her limbs, and even breathing felt difficult. Noel, a coworker, teased her that she would need a return-to-work bed. Missie did not laugh. Noel though his jokes would cheer her up, but she became increasingly hurt by them. She complained to her manager, Hannah, who quietly arranged for Noel to work elsewhere. By then, however, Missie had already retreated home. Missie’s doctor said she was suffering from depression and anxiety as a result of Noel’s bullying. By August, she’d been absent from work for a total of three months and two days. After receiving a medical certificate stating that Missie would remain off work for an indefinite period while she recovered from the bullying, Hannah spoke to HR. HR said the certificate was sufficient evidence and Missie’s employment was terminated.”

Andrew Douglas: See, you know who the person is who makes jokes to try and cheer people up who are angry?

Kim McLagan: Who is that?

Andrew Douglas: Me. You know how well it works?

Kim McLagan: Not very well.

Andrew Douglas: Not very well. Just thought I’d raise that in case anybody’s thinking of mirroring that behavior. So the first question was, “Was HR right that Missie’s employment could be terminated because she was not fit to perform the inherent requirements of her role?”

Kim McLagan: No. I don’t think they had sufficient medical evidence to be able to make that determination.

Andrew Douglas: No, they had to actually go and independently assess what the evidence was, and determine that and they didn’t do it. So that’s Toyota and Stergioti, just remember it. It’s clear breach. You’re going to lose every time. Could Hannah rely on the medical certificate as evidence that Missie was not fit to perform her role when deciding to terminate? It’s the same question you said before

Kim McLagan: Same issue, yeah.

Andrew Douglas: But no, if I provide you with a medical certificate, I haven’t interrogated the questions that need to be asked in that medical certificate to get the right responses. So yeah, she’s not fit, but are there adjustments which would allow? And when you say indefinite, do you mean forever? Or do you mean three to six months?

Kim McLagan: What does it mean?

Andrew Douglas: What does it mean? Not asked. Missie brought a general protections claim, alleging that her illness and her earlier complaints about Noel’s bullying involve workplace rights. What are the prospects of success?

Kim McLagan: Yeah, pretty good.

Andrew Douglas: Overwhelming, I would have thought. And why is that so? So when you look at a general protections claim, what Missie has to prove is that she had workplace right. She did. She had an illness. They knew about that illness, okay? And they wanted to move on that illness. A complaints around bullying, okay, which Noel did, and they’d recognized that by removing Noel, but they understood the impact that it had. And then they decided without proper evidence to terminate her. The reverse onus is there’s the adverse action, there’s the workplace right. The reverse onus, how do you say we decide to terminate her based on inadequate medical evidence, and think you can get away from general protections? You could never get away from it. It’s a lay down

Kim McLagan: That’s why the IMEs are so important. And that’s what I say to clients all the time, because it will protect you against any claim, workers’ comp, unfair dismissal or general protection.

Andrew Douglas: Just everything. Could Missie bring an anti-bullying application? Well she could, but she wouldn’t succeed.

Kim McLagan: Well she could, she wouldn’t succeed.

Andrew Douglas: Because she’s not there, okay? And that’s what I want to get through. She is not there, and more importantly, the person who bullied her is not there. The fact that she suffered an injury that takes her away from work, that’s all true, but that’s not what the bullying jurisdiction is about. Safety jurisdiction, yes. Workers’ comp injuries, yes, but not the anti-bullying.

Kim McLagan: Could Missie make… Oh, hang on. Oh, sorry, yes. Could Missie make a workers’ compensation claim and what are her prospects of success? Absolutely, yes.

Andrew Douglas: Yeah. And if you go back to the one you missed, the safety one.

Kim McLagan: Oh, that’s what I was thinking! Is there a breach of safety law?

Andrew Douglas: Yeah, so there’s three breaches of safety law. There’s a breach by organization, quite clearly, failing to do everything reasonably practical, provide a safe place of work, okay? Win. Probably not reckless endangerment or anything more serious, but there’s a primary duties breach. She raised a bullying complaint about safety and that was ignored and not acted upon and terminated. So there’s the discrimination provisions under the OHS Act that sit there. And of course our little mate, whoever his name is, Noel’s in a bit of strife as well under section 25 in Victoria, which is the same one that an individual must exercise reasonable care to prevent harm.

So there’s plenty of safety breaches just sitting in there, okay? But yeah, the workers’ comp is a winner, isn’t it? It doesn’t matter. With all the amendments that have been made, it fits within the New South Wales exception because it did involve a bullying behavior, okay? To see the different tests, fits inside workers’ comp, tick, bullying, because it did affect her health at work. It was unreasonable and it was repetitive. Doesn’t matter. It’s not ongoing. Tick. Fits inside the Victorian jurisdiction. It’s not usual and typical. It’s not reasonable management action and she suffered harm and harm was a predominant cause. So you can see, although there’s been changes to legislation in Victoria and New South Wales, and soon in Queensland, in every jurisdiction, this one will be accepted. So it’s great. I’m bit tired after this morning, yeah.

Kim McLagan: I’ll bet. No surprise.

Andrew Douglas: Great doing this one. It’s good. See you.

Kim McLagan: Thanks.

Andrew Douglas: Okay, see you next week. Cheers.

Secret Link