Andrew Douglas: And we’re really up to the main topic. And I know I’ve given you a bit of a blast in this, because to be candid with you, the arguments that are currently sitting before us politically are deeply offensive
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: to me personally and to who we are as a country. To think that we have a migration problem when we have a talent shortage is just a level of ignorance which is unbelievable. In country of Australia for the last 20 years, we have not had enough unskilled people to work rurally. We just haven’t. And every time we have an event like COVID, it demonstrates that we’re unable to maintain the farms that we have with the current levels of people that we’ve got. In our meat and food processing industries, as I say, in both areas, migrant labor, whether it’s backpacker or visa labor, represent 1/3 of the population of people who are working.
Madelyn Hassan: Yep.
Andrew Douglas: These businesses would close
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: and fail without them. And yet, politically, from no party do I hear any argument about the commercial futility of this argument.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: But it’s not only that, it’s in professional services. It’s in every… It’s in retail, it’s in hospitality.
Madelyn Hassan: Every sector.
Andrew Douglas: Australia has a huge talent shortage, which we supplement, we fight for, and we pay excessive prices for migrant labor under the schemes like the PALM scheme.
Madelyn Hassan: Yep.
Andrew Douglas: It’s hugely expensive. It’s highly bureaucratic. It’s very difficult. And yet, this nonsense is being propagated that we need to reduce the number. We need more migrants.
Madelyn Hassan: Yep.
Andrew Douglas: We actually need more migrants. And in case anybody who grew up in Australia didn’t know, actually, Australia was built upon indigenous lands by migrants. There is no, except the indigenous population, native Australians.
Madelyn Hassan: Yep.
Andrew Douglas: All of us generationally have come, me six generations ago as Scottish immigrants.
Madelyn Hassan: Yep.
Andrew Douglas: How many generations were you?
Madelyn Hassan: My father still lives in Syria and my mother was born here, but her parents are from Lebanon.
Andrew Douglas: So, can I just say, and aren’t we lucky we’ve got Madelyn? And yet, I… No, no, I mean it. And yet we hear this nonsense from white, dumb people
Madelyn Hassan: Mm-hm.
Andrew Douglas: saying we need to change the law. And yet, my culture here, in our firm alone, we have 18 different cultural bases that sit here. And of that 18 groups, 12 are first and second generation.
Madelyn Hassan: Yep.
Andrew Douglas: That’s 1/3 of our population of the people who work in my business who create the value in our business, who create that diversity in our business, come from migrant backgrounds, immediate migrant backgrounds. So, excuse me for feeling offended, but that’s where we are. What will the new legislation do in HR terms? I think Madelyn sort of summed it up brilliantly in the work she gave me. The first thing is it will cost a lot more to have a migrant
Madelyn Hassan: Mm-hm.
Andrew Douglas: and the supervision and mechanism for maintaining them will be more expensive to run and be much more highly invigilated.
Madelyn Hassan: Yep.
Andrew Douglas: So, for the people in country Victoria, I’m really sorry. It’s going to cost you more, even though your margins are so slim at the moment,
Madelyn Hassan: Mm-hm.
Andrew Douglas: to actually meet what you need and you will still have labor shortages.
Madelyn Hassan: Oh, 100%.
Andrew Douglas: The second thing that means is that we’re going to build a much more highly casualized labor force through labor hire suppliers who will have better access and capability delivering it. So, we will not get our own permanent employees. For the people who say less migration, do you really think that’s a great idea? ‘Cause you’re the same people who are saying, “We think it’s wrong that there is this whole casual labor force just floating out there.” Honestly.
Madelyn Hassan: Yep.
Andrew Douglas: The third thing that comes out of that is there will be some industries which just fail. That’s just it.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: So, for the unskilled backpacker type industries which are really going to, like, and that’s food processing and it’s horticulture. Those industries, I’m afraid many of them are going to go under because the cost
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: of getting labor and the lack of labor,
Madelyn Hassan: Oh, too much pressure, yeah.
Andrew Douglas: it’s just not going to happen.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: So, what really needs to come out of this is if you wish to use migrant labor and it’s likely the Labor government will lose, I’m not pretending I’m a good prognostican, but they’re stupid enough to have agreed with this discussion, which means they have no point of differentiation except failing as a government. What it means is you will need a dedicated migration plan. You will need to properly resource and access both migration lawyers and migration agents who can fulfil the criteria that is required, and you are going to be paying sponsorship in a very large bundle to actually keep the people you’ve got,
Madelyn Hassan: Yep.
Andrew Douglas: because labor hire will not succeed and has not succeeded as an industry in horticulture. What it’s done is it has reduced the margins in horticulture in a massive way,
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: and in meat processing. So, the times ahead are really turbulent, Madelyn, and I think they’re awful as well. Awful for our culture, awful for our businesses, and awful that we’d be having debate about a country which was built on migration, about migration. But what is difficult for organizations, critically difficult for organizations is don’t think you can wing migration. Migration will be going to the businesses who manage their migration process the best, have the proper plans, the proper lawyers, and the proper migration agents set up and have already located and identified who they’re bringing and how they’re bringing them. Just hope that backpackers attend. It ain’t going to work.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: Sad.
Madelyn Hassan: It is sad.
Andrew Douglas: It’s taking away a lot of the joy that lives within our community, but that’s where we are.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: Let’s just jump ahead now and let’s look at the case study. I’ll read it because I wrote it. Judy watched the door. Colin was due 30 minutes ago and her heartbeat was accelerating. Colin was an old fashioned boss. He preferred to deal with things face to face. He liked Judy, but she was struggling in the new store and he had little time to support her. While Judy was watching the door waiting for him to arrive, Colin was sitting in a car chatting with Kel from HR about what to do. Kel suggested a few KPIs that could help, including turnover, margins, wage control. Before sending Colin on his way, when Colin came to see Judy, he failed to notice her anxiety and got straight to the point.
The store was underperforming, and she’d been brought in to fix it. There was too much casual labor, too much overtime, revenue was lower than expected, and as a result, margins were down. She needed to lift her game. Judy explained that she’d achieved some of the revenue growth, but a major competitor opened down the street. The competitor was paying higher base rates, had better car parking, and offered a wider variety of stock. Colin frowned. “That’s why you’re here, to fix it,” he said before leaving. Judy felt powerless. She had no control over marketing, wages, or location. She was working long hours filling staffing gaps, and because she’s not an Award-covered employee, she received no additional pay for those hours. The following day, Kel sent through a performance improvement plan for Colin to work through with Judy.
The performance metrics were all outside of her control. She felt her pulse race and her head throb. She rang Colin in tears. Colin felt for her. He understood. Kel had not warned him about the PIP. Colin angrily called Kel and scolded him. Kel remained calm. “Look, Col, get your act together. I’m just getting ahead of what’s happening. She’s not going to make it.” Fortunately for Judy, she had planned leave to spend time with her daughter in Fiji and unwind. When she returned, Kel stood her down over an allegation of overordering. On the last day before taking leave, she’d placed an order with the warehouse. Unfortunately, one line of the order had become corrupted and repeated itself, doubling the quantity ordered.
The goods arrived while she was away and because they were perishable, some stock was wasted. Colin and Kel met with Judy, told her that the allegation had been substantiated and summarily terminated their employment. All right, you’re ready to go. Question one, would Judy have a good worker’s compensation claim prior to her termination? Absolutely. So, it doesn’t matter where you are for this particular part of it. The nature of the behavior and setting KPIs which are not reasonable and managing against something which can’t be met breaches reasonable management action in every jurisdiction, okay?
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah, yeah.
Andrew Douglas: So no, she would succeed. Did any of Judy’s performance issues meet the threshold test under Regulation 1.07 of the Fair Work Regulations? Okay, so 1.07 defines summary termination.
Madelyn Hassan: Mm-hm.
Andrew Douglas: So if we looked at them and we said, did her behavior fundamentally breach her contract of employment? No, was it a failure to comply with lawful and reasonable directions? There were directions.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: They could have been lawful, but they certainly. weren’t reasonable.
Madelyn Hassan: Weren’t reasonable.
Andrew Douglas: Did what she do create an imminent risk to the mental health or reputation of the organization or the financial welfare of the organization? No, ’cause the KPIs all fell outside of things that she can control, no?
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: Again, going back, was there a lawful and reasonable direction? Was she affected by drugs and alcohol?: No.
Andrew Douglas: So, the answer is there was no proper basis for summary termination.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: She would succeed in any claim that sat around that. Next question is, should Colin have been on notice of the risk under Burke and Suncorp? Burke and Suncorp was a 2015 case that said a person doesn’t have to tell you they’ve got a mental health issue. If a reasonable person observing the person’s appearance and conduct would form a view that they were impacted by some sort of mental health issue, under the obligation to do everything that’s reasonably practical to monitor someone’s health, you had to intervene. And I think this is a really good question.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: I don’t think there was enough to trigger Burke and Suncorp because there was crying during performance issues,
Madelyn Hassan: Mm-hm.
Andrew Douglas: and there’s a case called Northern Health which says everyone cries during that. That’s not unreasonable. There wasn’t absenteeism,
Madelyn Hassan: No.
Andrew Douglas: change of dress,
Madelyn Hassan: Yep.
Andrew Douglas: change of grooming, but we’re getting there. And I guess what I want to raise with you is that what we thought the obligations of monitoring health were in 2015 since psychological hazards I think have changed.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah, I agree with that.
Andrew Douglas: So, knowing someone’s stressed by a method of performance is enough because we’ve seen the cases run in the safety jurisdiction
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: to put you on notice of risk. But anyway, not quite there under employment law. Judy had raised concerns with Colin about how unfair the Performance Improvement Plan was and explained the impact it was having on her. When Colin told Kel, Kel exploded and said, “She’s got to go!” Would Judy have a strong General Protections claim and a safety discrimination claim? Hard question, isn’t it? I’m throwing it all at you today.
Madelyn Hassan: You are.
Andrew Douglas: Well, she’s raised a complaint around her safety, okay? So, she’s got a protected workplace right.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: Okay? Was she treated badly? Yes, she was terminated. So, was there some type of action that was taken that was adverse? Yes, it was. What was the mind of the decision maker at the time of taking that adverse action? Did it apply to the nature of the complaint? And what we’ve got evidence here of clearly is Kel says it does. “She’s got to go.”
Madelyn Hassan: He does, yeah.
Andrew Douglas: Now, what most people don’t understand is under the Safety Act in every state and jurisdiction, whether it’s WHS or Victoria OH and S Act, there is an anti-discrimination provision that was primarily put there to protect HSRs, but also for any other person who raised a safety complaint. And just like general protections, it’s a reverse onus. So yes, it is a prosecutable and a civil wrong
Madelyn Hassan: Mm-hm.
Andrew Douglas: under safety legislation. Last question. I hope it’s the last question ’cause I’m running out of breath. Were there any other safety breaches? And if so, who is responsible and what would be the likely outcome if prosecuted? And the answer is yes, there is.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: Okay? Reasonable practicability means you must identify, was there a hazard? In the managing of her, she’s raised the fact
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: that there are psychological hazards. She doesn’t feel safe in the manner in which it’s being dealt with, and it’s not being dealt with reasonably.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: So, their treatment of her and her experience of it, both hazards, okay?
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: And their treatment moves to one of the more egregious styles because it is repeated,
Madelyn Hassan: Mm-hm.
Andrew Douglas: it is unreasonable, and it is affecting her safety at work. And whether we like it or not, guys, that’s called bullying, okay?
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: So, the next question is, what is the control? There is no control.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: So she is, then, in her duty sense, I have to do everything reasonably practical to provide a safe place to work. No, it’s not.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: I have to do everything that’s reasonably practical to have a system and supervision in place. No, I haven’t got that. They’re actually quite serious breaches.
Madelyn Hassan: There is, yeah.
Andrew Douglas: So, the short answer, I’m afraid, is unquestionably, organization is liable, but also her direct manager on his personal liability to exercise reasonable care to prevent harm
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: is liable as well. And Kel could get roped in because he is a player in the decision making, which makes an HR person drawn into the safety area.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: Just a bit of a warning for young players there.
Madelyn Hassan: Yeah.
Andrew Douglas: So look, that’s us for this week. Great to do it with you. Thanks very much for coming in.
Madelyn Hassan: Thank you.
Andrew Douglas: Please hit the link below and enjoy.