FCW Lawyers

Daily Brief 27 April 2020 | Psychological Injury – Documents, documents and more documents!


Psychological Injury – Documents, documents and more documents!

I realise now how we, as lawyers, must drive our clients crazy asking them to meticulously document their conversations and decisions. But two cases in the last week remind me why I do it.

The risk of documents when you don’t act

In Swiderski V Addelaide Oval Management Authority, Mr Swiderski was successful in the South Australian Employment Tribunal, in gaining discovery of all of his employers notes and documents of the complaints he made about their mistreatment of him. Some had been withheld. His argument will be a trial, that he was bullied and harassed and that lead to his mental injury. The obvious question to ask is why didn’t they hand them over? If he can show that his mental injury arose from mistreatment, his claim will be successful.

Good documents

In contrast, the case of Batista v Wells Fargo demonstrates why excellent documentation, that evidences actions and sheds light on the reasons for decisions are so powerful.

Mr Batista initially took time off work for a meltdown. He made complaints against his manager, Ms Rhodes, of bullying (making a complaint to the FWC for a Stop Bullying Orders) leading to her being placed on administrative leave whilst investigated and generally suggested he had a mental disability. At the conclusion of the investigation against Ms Rhodes, his employment was terminated. The evidence, supported by documents prepared by the Wells Fargo employees, showed a history of repeated breach of policies and misconduct and no bullying and harassment. It evidenced the intentions of the decision-maker at all times was focused fairly on the conduct and that the termination was reasonable.

What are good documents?

The three key things are:

  1. Must be made at the time of the undertaking the task (when counselling for example)
  2. Must capture exactly what the issue is and facts (not opinions)
  3. When you make a decision explain in the document why you made the decision (particularly in adverse action claims it is the subjective intention of the decision maker that is critical).

Have a question or need advice?

Our team are available to clarify any questions to have and provide the right advice for your business and workforce. Please contact Andrew Douglas at andrew.douglas@fcwlawyers.com.au or on 0488 151 503.

Stay updated through our Friday Workplace Briefing Webinars

Every Friday at 10:30am, join us on your device of choice for a free webinar to stay updated on the critical news and developments that affect your workplace. We’ll keep it simple, pragmatic and to 30 minutes. Watch, listen and interact with us, as we address the pressing topics and questions that impact your business and people. We are here to help and look forward having you with us.